Photo of Phillies Ace Roy Halladay by Icon SMI

Going by the numbers for this award, I analyzed the following metrics: wins minus losses plus strikeouts, walks minus intentional walks (because that’s usually situational), WHIP (walks and hits per innings pitched), ERA minus SIERA (a new Baseball Prospectus stat that reflects a pitcher’s true ERA). Points were also deducted for wild pitches, balks, hit batters and home runs allowed.

Additional stats not taken into this analysis were the winner’s complete games (9) and shutouts (4 of those 9 games). One of these games being a Perfect game (no hits or walks allowed).

The winner is Phillies Ace Roy “Doc” Halladay

The Stan Musial Award

Albert Pujols Photo by Icon SMI

Going by the numbers for this award, I analyzed the following metrics: runs scored, RBIs, total bases, added the number of intentional walks to add weight to that stat (it usually shows the reluctance to face a certain batter), stolen bases minus times caught stealing, batting average, OBP and then I subtracted strikeouts.

I would have persoanally preferred to see new blood win this award, but Pujols is well deserving of it this year! He beat Reds 1B Joey Votto in runs, RBI, total bases, walks (with 30 more intentional walks than Votto), less K’s with more hits, doubles and home runs. How could Pujols not win it when you look at it that way?

*denotes Honorable Mentions

Coming into 2009, Zobrist was a little-known utility player, who had never done all that much in the big leagues. He had a decent season in 2008, but hitting 12 home runs in only 62 games, still isn’t going to get you much national recognition. He clearly entered his prime this season, though, putting up ridiculous numbers at the age of 28.

So why is he more valuable than say, Albert Pujols? Well, as amazing as Pujols is, he’s overrated in some respects. I can’t take anything away from his hitting, as he’s obviously one of the best hitters to ever step into the box, but his defense, is nothing special. He had two excellent defensive seasons in ’07 and ’08, but he’s topped out at a 4.6 UZR in his other 7 seasons, and in 2009 he only hit 1.2. He’s still an above average first baseman, but not quite enough of one this year.

Ben Zobrist, on the other hand, boasts a spectacular combination of excellent defense at several positions, and a well above average bat. He split most of his time between second base and right field this year, posting a 15.6 and 11.4 UZR, respectively. He not only has shown that he has excellent range, but his arm was 3.7 runs above average out in right this season.

Now, when you compare the offense of the two, Pujols takes the cake. His .449 wOBA in 2009 was spectacular, even when compared to the .408 clip Zobrist put up (the NL average is .329, the AL average is .302).

So, when you factor in both offense and defense, Albert Pujols comes in at 73.3 runs above average, while Zobrist comes in at 66.1. When you factor in the league differences, Zobrist was worth 8.5 wins, while Pujols was worth 8.4. Obviously, it’s extremely close, but when you consider the fact that Pujols made $14.4 million this season, and Zobrist made $415k, it’s pretty remarkable.

So I’m saying Zobrist deserves to win the AL MVP award, right? Actually, no. Joe Mauer comes in at a close 3rd place behind the two in WAR, and when you think about the fact that catcher’s defense isn’t quantifiable, and therefore doesn’t factor into WAR, you have to assume that Mauer would easily pass both of them. Joe Mauer is your MVP, but Ben Zobrist is a close second, not just in the AL, but in all of baseball.